Also, Smaug is a smaller dragon. Hot New Top. Shelve Unfinished Tales of Númenor and Middle-Earth. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. This may be why Sauron's physical repository for his willpower was the Ring and not the land itself like Morgoth. One of the Valar (Eru's Angels), Aulë (the maker, the sort of Hephaestus of Arda) grew impatient awaiting the arrival Eru's Children (Elves and Men) and created the Dwarves in secret... they were purely mechanical lifeless beings at first as Eru hadn't infused them with life. Well, in the First Age, Morgoth, the first Dark Lord, had literally armies of both. Its take on Lord of the … Unfinished and Lost Tales are sort of...unreliable, as well. Who would your choices be instead? Fool Elrond once, shame on you. I often go back to the books because I find Gandalf's attitude so forceful. Rate it ... help Reddit App Reddit coins Reddit premium Reddit gifts. The giant firebeast thing is defeated by Gandalf when he destroys the bridge, sending the creature plunging to its death... despite the fact that it has wings. At the 2019 summer Television Critics Association press tour, Amazon revealed the creative team behind the new Lord of the Rings prequel series. One of the Valar (Eru's Angels), Aulë (the maker, the sort of Hephaestus of Arda) grew impatient awaiting the arrival Eru's Children (Elves and Men) and created the Dwarves in secret... they were purely mechanical lifeless beings at first as Eru hadn't infused them with life. We emphasise serious discussion here over jokey/meme-based posts. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. When Elrond is examining Glamdring and tells Gandalf that the sword belonged to the king of Gondolin, that's his great grandfather he's referring to. r/lotro Rules. It is a good time to rewatch, or even watch for the first time, the movies set in Middle Earth. And are you sure it isn't the European use of corn for grain, not American maize? For most average people reading it for the first time can be quite a challenge. In LOTRO, LMs debuff enemies, buff … For all things Tolkien, Lord of The Rings, and The Hobbit ... Press J to jump to the feed. When realistically he is v powerful. I agree with your points, here. When Peter Jackson first started planning The Lord Of The Rings films back in 1995, he couldn’t have imagined how it would dominate his life. Lord of the Rings Doormat Emblazoned with Gandalf’s famous phrase, this doormat will be sure to keep out unwanted balrogs and orcs. Smaug was a greedy, reddish-gold dragon of Middle-earth, who laid waste to Dale and captured the Lonely Mountain (Erebor) with all its treasure, which he gathered in a central hall and slept upon. Trotter is a revered name in our home. Edit: evidently this is genuinely an unpopular opinion lol. The first-age hidden Elvish city of Gondolin was assailed by an army of mecha dragons piloted by orcs (Lost Tales 2 - The Fall of Gondolin). Before he turned bad, Sauron was in the servant of a higher being called Aulë who was a master and lover of craft. As a big time Aragorn fan could you expand on why his claim is shady? Tolkien is a much better writer than people give him credit for. Finishing "The Lord of The Rings" led to further changes which were eventually rolled into "The Silmarillion," even though that book is largely concerned with events that precede "The Hobbit" and "The Lord of the Rings" — and it was drafted before both novels were written. Tolkien’s Middle-earth - best known through The Lord of The Rings is populated by some of the most powerful characters in fantasy.. And I'm pretty sure orcs have trouble with the Sun because it is the more intense of the remnants of the Two Trees. Eru Ilúvatar was of course aware of Aulë's transgression, but instead of making Aulë destroy his creation, he put the fathers of the Dwarves to sleep until the Firstborn (the Elves) and the lesser Children (Men) arrived in Arda at their appointed time. What happened in the realm of Moria / Khazad Dum before we see it in The Lord of the Rings The Fellowship of the Ring? (Unfinished Tales). Sauron would've won if the Ring hadn't been destroyed. They just yell at the gate and then run back the moment it opens. Frodo is made to look like a gullible idiot, doubly so in the extended edition (‘Sméagol promised!’ ‘Sméagol lied’) whereas in the books he is eventually right about Gollum, extended scenes are a mixed bag in the other movies, in ROTK they are mostly bad (lowlights: Aragorn beheading a messenger, Witch-King breaking Gandalf’s staff, S K U L L A V A L A N C H E). Elrond probably could have claimed the sword as a direct descendant if he had wanted to. Saved by Peter McLeod. They didn't take the Eagles to Mordor because Sauron's forces would've seen them coming, they could've been caught by the Nazgûl upon their fell beasts, or shot down by archers. What are the casting misses? Arwen's grandma was half Maia (basically a "lesser angel"). Despite having accumulated such vast wealth, Smaug was intimately familiar with every last item within his hoard, and instantly noticed the theft of a relatively inconsequential item by Bilbo Baggins. Rising. The massive lore of Lord of the Rings can not be contained in one statue but Prime 1 Studio can try. They didn't take the Eagles to Mordor because Sauron's forces would've seen them coming, they could've been caught by the Nazgûl upon their fell beasts, or shot down by archers. It's just a plot hole. We talk about it here! Then He granted them life. For me I recently reread The Hobbit for first time in many years (29 now probably teens since last read) but wow I was surprised by it and how different it felt this time around. The mouth of sauron is actually the scene I always bring up as being one of the strangest ones to not see in the theatrical version. I doubt you are alone on this, though I myself love both mediums as equals. Return of the King is by far the worst of the three LOTR films. The very first thing Bilbo Baggins thought of when he first picked up the Ring was bacon. Middle-earth in the Third Age is much smaller than it was in the First because the Valar (archangels, essentially) and Morgoth (a fallen Vala) got into a cage match. User account menu. I love all the revisions discussed in the HoME. Please keep discussion civil. Me too, It's become a habit after reading The Silmarillion. This was retracted when a reader pointed out that the wings, like the rest of the beast, were made of shadow and fire and thus would be useless for flight. card. Luthien was 1/2. Her son, Elwing's father, Dior, was 1/4 maia. Self explanatory really, what aspect of the the movies, books, lore etc do you hold a very unpopular opinion of? 1/7. This subreddit is a space for the Tolkien nerds of reddit to debate and discuss the whole Tolkien mythos. It's a strong opinion, however unpopular: While Ian McKellan is a great actor, he played Gandalf much more modestly and far less confidently than the Gandalf of the books. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts Good take. You need to grow and find a new place in the world, not run back to one that's always going to be there. Tolkien created for Middle Earth, Lord of the Rings star Elijah Wood thinks Amazon should consider renaming their television adaptation. The Lore-master is a main support class … The Gandalf of the films, however, is often prone to looking hopeless, greatly pained, or caught off guard. Since I’m getting downvoted let me explain (in truncated form since I’ve had this conversation before): Peter Jackson misunderstands the Army of the Dead and how they work. Same for all the other Valar. For all the lore J.R.R. For a maia he does seem troubled a lot and much more humble. He even has already created what the seas will be in the future. In "The Lord of the Rings: The Two Towers" (2002) when Elrond tries to convince Arwen to leave middle-earth for the undying lands of Valinor, one can see in the background a tapestry of the Two Trees Laurelin and Telperion, who - before the creation of sun and moon - brought light to Arda. Lord of the Rings r/ lordoftherings. All pretty much contrary to how the story as a whole would come together after it veered away from being a simple sequel to The Hobbit. What is your Lord of the Rings/Tolkien unpopular opinion? The casting in the movie has a lot of hits, but a lot of misses that fans have either talked themselves into, or don't want to admit. u/chi0408's unpopular LOTR opinion is that "the editing in [The … Log In Sign Up. The Dwarves are a hiccup in the cosmological development of the world as envisioned by Eru Ilúvatar (the Creator). (The Hobbit), The reason the goblins and orcs couldn't come out during the daytime is because they evolved before the Sun and Moon existed at all. I am sure that is not an unpopular opinion around here, but he doesn't get enough credit elsewhere. Although I still love his take on Gandalf, if Christopher Lee got his wish and played Gandalf he would have been different I would say more inline what you wished you had seen. In J.R.R. The Lore Master is a main support class. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. And now, six … A podcast about The Lord of the Rings: The Card Game, which is a Living Card Game by Fantasy Flight Games. Strider was originally called "Trotter." Sting ($162,500) Sting obviously plays a very important role in The Lord of the Rings and is therefore … Histories of Middle Earth are often quite dense as I'm finding but totally worth it for the hilarious and awesome fun facts you find about early versions of the Silmarillion and the Lord of the Rings. But this is just preference, I know most people would not agree with this. The result is the unstoppable green wave in the films, which severely takes away from the drama and spectacle at the Battle of the Pelennor Fields and creates plot holes that didn’t exist in the book, Denethor being reduced to an insane idiot makes the whole Gondor subplot far less interesting, Gollum is already beyond redemption and sympathy by this point in the movies, so all the drama in Frodo’s story comes from the manufactured feud with Sam. And while I think that Peter Jackson may have had a hand in that, I would have loved to have seen a more confident, inspiring Gandalf who stayed truer to the books, and was a real force to be reckoned with. card classic compact. Galadriel is over 8,000 years old and was born before the Sun and Moon were put in the sky. However, the last note he has on them suggests there were never more than 7, and perhaps fewer. In this episode we explore whether Good Orcs existed in Middle-Earth and if not, whether they could ever exist. Not completely, but it was written for his children no...? Unlike say, Poseidon, who drew lots for his domain, Ulmo is ruler of the seas because he created the seas. J.R.R. Further actions taken as necessary. The subreddit for the game Lord of the Rings Online.Now free to play, get it HERE!. Saying dragons are mechs is embellishing a bit, don't you think? He knows everything about the seas, and that is the source of his power. 1.8k. (Silmarillion), Christopher Tolkien figured out that Galadriel is canonically 6'4". This is why the Dwarves are makers, delvers of great subterranean cities and hardy as fuck... and are also somewhat resentful of both Elves and Men. The trilogy is quite a slog to get into. The Dwarves are a hiccup in the cosmological development of the world as envisioned by Eru Ilúvatar (the Creator). Canon is a touchy subject, though. Arwen's Grandmothers are Galadriel on her mother's side, and Elwing on her Father's. Elwing herself was 1/8. If a movie is exciting and adventurous it is surely much more difficult for those watching to dislike them. Her name was Lúthien Tinúviel. *RETRACTED REASONS LORD OF THE RINGS SUCKS: 11. Remember how dangerous and terrifying a single Balrog (Durin's Bane) and a single dragon (Smaug) were in the Third Age? Official website for The Lord of the Rings Online™ with game information, developers diaries, frequently asked questions and message boards. Sauron was once a cat named Tevildo and there was an epic war between dogs and cats (Lost Tales 1 - Tale of Tinúviel). Every time I read it, I just wish JRR Tolkien had the chance to finish and/or expand the stories. The Silmarillion is the best book. The plan to destroy the Ring only worked because Sauron never even considered that it would be destroyed -- he expected everyone to try and claim it or hide it. The Lord of the Rings is a really familiar IP, so it lets folks know about the world the show is set in. This statue is highly detailed and packed with some amazing craftsmanship. Our family named our (sadly long since passed away) golden retriever after him. Self explanatory really, what aspect of the the movies, books, lore etc do you hold a very unpopular opinion of? Posts or comments badmouthing the game or it's users will be removed. 2017 Gameplay of the Lore Master (LM) class in the Lord of of the Rings Online (LOTRO). First 150 page or so of the fellow ship is a snooze for most people. Feb 6, 2021 - Explore Sarah Lee's board "Funny Clean Lord of the Rings" on Pinterest. I enjoy the movies much more than the books, and think they are a tighter narrative and more hopeful/inspiring. Return Of The King Is Actually Bad. Join. Aragorn's claim to the throne of Gondor is shady at best a bit suspect totally legitimate. Though to be fair the added dimension of music in the movies adds to that feeling of inspiration and hope does it not? Osgiliath was once the capital of Gondor, built by Anarion and Isildur when they first landed in Middle-Earth. For all things Tolkien, Lord of The Rings, and The Hobbit ... Press J to jump to the feed. That's not to say you have to be a LOTR scholar or Tolkien academic to post or enjoy this subreddit, but that we'd prefer not to have image macros or movie gifs filling up this forum. Do't even @ me, mellon. r/LotRLore: We aim to document all of J. R. R. Tolkien's legendarium. They swoop in and save the charters from certain doom when all hope is lost. Tolkien's book series The Lord of the Rings, as well as the subsequent film adaptations by Peter Jackson, Sauron is an ancient evil who forges the Ring of Power in an attempt to rule Middle-Earth once and for all.Determined to stop Sauron, Elrond, an Elf, forms a council to decide who will make the journey to destroy the Ring, assembling a fellowship of nine adventurers with … For me The Hobbit gets less enjoyable with each read, recently read it for first time in many years (29 now probably teens since last read) but wow I was surprised by it and how different it felt this time around. Fool Elrond twice, shame on Elrond. Tom Bombadil is the Stan Lee of Lord of the Rings The much-debated character is not that mysterious if you know Tolkien By Susana Polo @NerdGerhl Jan 20, 2021, 2:05pm EST Their are a lot of child like elements to it.. the elves literally just laugh and sing and dance about. Tolkien's style of writing isn't for everyone, I think people have specific styles of writing they find more easier or more enjoyable to get through whereas movies I think people are much more tolerant of. Sauron was bad at combat, and his mentor (Morgoth) was a coward. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. Though Smeagol imo takes the crown. They're entirely different characters, it just happened that Sauron took over the role played by Tevildo in the Lay of Leithan. The Valar and their Maiar have power over the world, because they created it: past, present, and future. had to log in to comment on how wrong you are, or at least how far from correct you are... basically everything you wrote except for 1,2,5, and 9 to some extent is wrong. Tolkien admits in his letters the Eagles are his Deus Ex Machina. r/lotr: For all things Tolkien, Lord of The Rings, and The Hobbit ... Press J to jump to the feed. Damn you, gravity! Actually Tolkien never definitively settled on a final number for Balrogs. Like much of Peter Jackson’s The Lord of the Rings films or, say, Game of Thrones, Amazon’s take on Tolkien’s world will be populated by a cast of … At one point Tolkien had Bingo (Frodo) putting on the ring at Farmer Maggot's, prancing around with a mug of beer then stealing the farmer's hat on the way out the door. Hot. In the Second Age it took Gil-galad and Elendil to defeat him, both of which perished in the act. Wouldn't disagree he is well up there with the best. Press J to jump to the feed. sometimes I like to imagine galadriel serving it with fried chicken and collards. For the first several thousand years of its history, Arda (the world in which Middle-earth is contained) was flat. Hot New Top Rising. That's not quite accurate. It's no different than R2D2 having total control over every machine in the Star Wars universe at need be. Rings of men. The Lord of the Rings is a film series of three epic fantasy adventure films directed by Peter Jackson, based on the novel written by J. R. R. Tolkien.The films are subtitled The Fellowship of the Ring (2001), The Two Towers (2002), and The Return of the King (2003). Ancalagon the Black destroyed a mountain range when he died. Arwen and Aragorn are first cousins some 60 times removed. Also, he had more orcs than Anfauglith - a barren plain about the size of Gondor and Mordor combined - could hold at once. And I encourage others to look at some of this best lines. Read the Silmarillion if you're interested in the history of Middle Earth. His speech to Frodo early in the fellowship tears me up just thinking about it. reddit: the front page of the internet. I would also add that a huge point of the story is lost in the removal of the Scouring of the Shire. See more ideas about lord of the rings, the hobbit, lord. Gets much better after the council of elrond. Fool Elrond a third time, fuck it … 2018 Gameplay of the Lore Master (LM) class in the Lord of of the Rings Online (LOTRO) in 2018 and Mordor. The secret path through Shelob's lair was the only real way into Mordor. I don't think so. This epic drama is set thousands of years before the events of J.R.R. Lord of The Rings r/ lotr. Guess it may be as you get older but elements of it feel so different (albeit it it was written before LOTR and all) but I can't see myself wanting to read it again for many years to come in all honesty. Théoden is the best character. It’s also pretty unlikely to be part of the actual final title. Sadly, lightning couldn’t strike twice for Melbourne House. We use cookies on our websites for a number of purposes, including analytics and performance, functionality and advertising. ... help Reddit App Reddit coins Reddit premium Reddit gifts. Not evolution, as they were corrupted from...something by Morgoth. The Lord of the Rings creative fellowship has formed. Lord of the Rings. They're a pleasure to read. In the First Age he turned himself into a giant werewolf and went toe to toe with Huan, the Hound of Valinor. One thing about Gandalf was that he always radiated great confidence, and even when he wasn't sure about something, he was sure of himself: he was happy to boat of his abilities, and he never gave in to despair. Join Chad, Chris, Jon, and company as they explore the … The whole point was that you can't go back to the home you left. Posted by 21 hours ago. A perfect housewarming gift. My biggest problem with the film version of the Return of the King is the crippling of Wizards in general, and the portrayal of the army of the Dead showing up in the middle of the day as an unstoppable force in battle. Neither are half maia. https://www.reddit.com/r/tolkienfans/comments/5epcqh/if_tolkien_was_sitting_across_from_you_and_told/. We use cookies on our websites for a number of purposes, including analytics and performance, functionality and advertising. Is there a reference for this?